Faith Hope and Shoo Fly

Faith Hope and Shoo Fly was formed in the fall of 2012 as a sister company of McClures Bakery and is located in the heart of Amish country in Lancaster County PA. McClures has been baking the very best cakes, pies breads and more since 1974.

McClures Pies

We are now partnering with Goldbely.com to deliver you the same great Shoo Fly Pie you have always known!

This will allow us to offer faster and better shipping options. Portions of our profits will still go to helping kids in need.

demo-image
Baking Schedule

We bake Shoo Fly Pies Monday through Thursday and ship the same day to ensure maximum freshness. For example, orders placed on Friday will be baked and shipped the following Monday.

Our Mission

We believe that love is an action and we decided that our actions of making pies each day would be used to express our love for those in need, so that is why when we say faith hope and shoo fly we are really saying faith hope and love.

Your Order Can Make a Difference!

A portion of all sales will go to Operation Underground Railroad and Camp Hill At The Old Mill. Thank You for helping!


Operation Underground Railroad

Operation Underground Railroad is a non-profit which assists governments around the world in the rescue of human trafficking and sex trafficking victims, with a special focus on children. Visit Operation Underground Railroad website.


Camp At The Old MillCamp at Old Mill works with churches and organizations, the Old Mill staff and facilities are dedicated to bringing youth into a relationship with Christ through summer camping programs, kid’s clubs and other year-round activities. Visit Camp At Old Mill website.

-